French director Jacques Audiard's musical about a Mexican drug lord is a top contender for the Academy Awards' major accolades. However, its portrayal of Mexico has sparked criticism.
Critics and industry figures in Mexico have expressed concerns regarding the limited involvement of Mexican talent in prominent cast and crew roles and the portrayal of the country in the film, particularly in addressing a sensitive subject matter.
Audiard's decision to primarily film outside Paris and the film's approach to such a challenging national topic has stirred discontent among many in Mexico, including Guillén, who states, "I wanted to get another vision out of what Emilia Pérez is to many of us Mexicans."
While some critique the casting choices, noting that Gomez and Saldaña are more globally recognized compared to many Mexican actors, concerns have been raised regarding the authenticity of their performances in the context of Mexican culture.
Despite some inaccurate criticisms directed at Audiard, who had visited Mexico for research and casting, the director explains his decision to infuse the film with a stylized vision unique to his perspective, akin to how Shakespeare crafted stories without physically being in their settings.
The film has sparked diverse reactions, with some praising its innovative blend of themes and storytelling elements, while others question its handling of sensitive topics and lack of authentic representation.
As the debates over cultural authenticity in storytelling unfold, individuals like Guillén advocate for more inclusivity and collaboration with creators native to the culture being depicted, emphasizing the importance of respectfully engaging with sensitive subjects.
"Emilia Pérez" is now streaming on Netflix worldwide.